Jeez comparing the Aero 15x right next to the GS65. Both look so good
-
Support.1@XOTIC PC Company Representative
-
Crying free speech goes both ways - there have been posts suppressed in this thread due to this "situation"...Last edited: May 14, 2018hmscott likes this. -
The trackpads, keyboards, speakers, and even the display built in I look at as fall back functional substitutes for much better external tools.
Keeping my human hands off the keyboard / laptop and distancing myself from the laptop with an external keyboard / mouse / trackpad greatly reduces the need to replace the keyboard due to liquid spills and keycap / switch failures over time. $100-200 / laptop or more saved over time.
I also carry a keyboard / trackpad / mouse in my backpack for work use, again saving wear and tear on the built in components, while uplifting my input experience many times over.
Headphones, external speakers, external monitors also round out fixed position use, enhancing the functional input experience greatly. I usually use the display even when connected to an external monitor, even at 18.4" for a built in display I still prefer a much larger external screen.
There are times I need the built in keyboard / trackpad, and display alone, even using battery, but they are all rare and I can deal with the inadequacies aok when doing so.
I've seen people not get a great performing laptop due to speakers, less often due to keyboard / trackpad, but for me I can work around most of the built-in parts of the laptop, except for the CPU and GPU and Display, as long as those are top notch for the price, and I can tune them for my use, the rest is replaceable with external components that are much better than can be fit into the laptop.o0Spoonman0o likes this. -
Spartan@HIDevolution, Donald@Paladin44 and Papusan like this.
-
Anyway, whatever.hmscott likes this. -
I forgot that I took these before I sold off my Razer Blade v5 14" - comparison of a 14" laptop versus the 15.6" GS65:
Also - for those that care - the Amazon Basics 14" sleeve does not fit this laptop, you'll need the 15.6" one. It's a bit big, but whatever.pau1ow likes this. -
Why post such comments (aka the first one) on the forum in the first place? Pretty unnecessary. But now it's time to move on. OK?
Iandv, BourbonAndIce, Spartan@HIDevolution and 2 others like this. -
hmscott likes this.
-
For the records... I and a few on the forum have pushed on companies like etc HID and talked about the (benefits with use of Liquid metal) and that they should offer it (still a higher risk than put on ordinary thermal paste). I'm happy they listening on us. Call it expensive HIDEvolution add-ons is quite special. And if I remember correct... I mean it was me or @Mr. Fox who pushed bro @Phoenix in the right direction (Use Liquid metal). Of course he will bring it out to the others Rememeber not all resellers offer this nice option.Last edited: May 14, 2018Spartan@HIDevolution, raz8020, skman and 1 other person like this. -
Donald@Paladin44 Retired
MSI GS65 8RF Stealth THIN-068
With no undervolt, after AIDA64 stress test, several benchmarks and at least 1.5 hours of intense gaming at Ultimate settings...these are the highest temperature spikes we recorded.
Stock:
GPU = 79C - CPU 92C
With Grizzly Conductonaut + Fujipoly Extreme Thermal Pads:
GPU = 75C - CPU = 84C -
http://forum.notebookreview.com/thr...-owners-and-discussions-lounge.815216/page-31 -
Donald@Paladin44 Retired
The information here is incorrect. https://www.techradar.com/reviews/msi-gs65-stealth
None of the current GS65 models have the switch which has the fingerprint reader function...never had it.
MSI will be releasing a replacement for the MSI GS65 8RF Stealth THIN-068 around July, same configuration, same price, but it will be the first model that has the fingerprint reader switch. Others may follow in time.Iandv likes this. -
Spartan@HIDevolution Company Representative
Jzyftw and Donald@Paladin44 like this. -
Tomorrow FedEx delivers my laptop... Unfortunately, I'm in the hospital for a few more days but look forward to trying it!Donald@Paladin44 and Spartan@HIDevolution like this. -
Edit: I’m leaning toward the MSI rep being wrong. Looking at the GS65 configuration page, there is clearly a new SKU GS65 Stealth THIN-259. If you look all the way down the list of specs to the notes section it clearly states “Fingerprint scanner” while none of the other SKUs share the note. Looks like we got bamboozled by the script given to early reviwers and we fell for it.Last edited: May 15, 2018Donald@Paladin44 and ctrlbrk like this. -
Hi all - Owner of a GS65 as well. Love the system but have an issue.
I'm curious has anyone else experiencing the "Intel + NVIDIA Laptop Freeze Problem " as described in (there a plenty of other places on the net that speak about it as well)
We are talking micro freezes/mouse freeze for a short burst while doing certain things.
Right click Display Settings on Desktop, Click on Battery on taskbar, etc...
https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us.../93e7004a-62b1-4211-8e37-4c136608865e?page=76
Seems like an issue that has been with Optimus/NVIDIA/Intel for quite some time - and it's quite annoying on new $2000 laptop.
Any ideas?Donald@Paladin44 likes this. -
Yes, it's a known problem and at the moment it affects ALL the laptops with Nvidia Optimus. It happens rarely, fortunally.
At the moment, the only solution that I know is to deactivate the Nvidia board when not needed.Donald@Paladin44 likes this. -
I'm glad to see it's a common issue and not machnie specific (although I would've thought it'd get fixed sooner that way?).. definitely experiencing the battery icon freeze quite often. Just a slight annoyance but not a big deal
Donald@Paladin44 likes this. -
Donald@Paladin44 likes this.
-
Phoenix mentioned in another thread that there was a way to fix it with an unlocked bios. I never got around to testing it.Donald@Paladin44 and TheGhastSlayer like this. -
Spartan@HIDevolution Company Representative
This is the latest Intel Graphics Driver = https://downloadmirror.intel.com/27780/a08/win64_15.40.38.4963.exe
Uninstall the old one then reboot, then install this one and reboot
If that doesn't fix your issue, let me knowDonald@Paladin44 and sk3tch like this. -
No need to get defensive, you can see my useful posts in the past few pages. I am not bashing anyone, just calling into question some of the practices on this forum.hmscott likes this. -
-
But I do recall you mentioning somewhere that there is a bios setting that is causing the issue and something needed to be disabled in order to fix it. I'm pretty sure it was you but I just looked back and can't find the thread. It wasn't a default setting though and required an unlocked bios to see it. I was just curious if that was still a fix or not. -
hmscott likes this.
-
Hey all! Looking forward to picking one of these up. Specifically, the 068 model. I'm planning to add on the Thermal Grizzly/FujiPoly pads, but is there anything else I should look at? Specifically, is this laptop known for backlight bleed issues or dead pixel issues? Trying to decide if I should buy either of those warranties.
Donald@Paladin44 likes this. -
Look at Best Buy they have a model for $2000 that is the sweet spot, really.
Happy to assist with using Intel XTU, etc. It's really easy.Last edited: May 15, 2018hmscott likes this. -
As for the repaste -- it may not be a big effect but that coupled with the XTU stuff should be good. From the results I saw earlier in the thread, it was a 5ish degree reduction. Which is about 5% from what I can tell. I'm very paranoid when it comes to heat in any machine I run so I'd rather be overkill in this department than run things at the line. That said, I'll definitely reach out for help with the XTU stuff when it gets to that point...unless it requires futzing around with hardware, at which point I'd probably be out haha.Donald@Paladin44 likes this. -
Spartan@HIDevolution Company Representative
Donald@Paladin44 and ctrlbrk like this. -
Spartan@HIDevolution Company Representative
Donald@Paladin44 likes this. -
https://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16834154803
Checks your boxes for 32GB and 1TB. I will say, you could get away with 256GB or 512GB storage and 16GB of RAM pretty easily and save some coin. But it is all about what you are looking for!hmscott likes this. -
I'll continue to debate on this and make a decision asap, though. Thanks for the suggestions!Donald@Paladin44 likes this. -
Donald@Paladin44 likes this.
-
Donald@Paladin44 Retired
What MSI actually tells reviewers, and what the reviewer hears, can be two different things.ctrlbrk likes this. -
Hey guys. Just receieved my GS65-054 from ibuypower. Hasn't been that many reviews with the company but I thought I'd share. I just got the standard 16gb ( 2 x 8gb) and a 256 nVme with thermal kryonaut and a fresh install of windows. It came as ordered and on time with them sending me texts as it was going through their process. I managed to get mine at a discount from their site and I'm really happy with it (always have a 5% off code). Funny they shipped it with a CD of windows 10 pro reinstallation hahahaha...... nice joke guys (didn't have to pay for that). The really cool thing is they shipped it with the thermal grizzly kryonaut used package with leftover compound to show me that they in fact did it.
Some notes about the laptop... The display is just amazing!!! No picture or youtube video came close to how great it is. It's even brighter than I thought and only a small amount of flex. It's so thin I'm afraid to break it since I've never had such a thin screen before. There is some flex in the chassis, BUT I realized that when I was testing the flex I was pressing pretty hard and noticed my asus gl703vm was doing the same and i never noticed. That being said, it's basically a non issue since there is no flex when typing and you'll think it flexes so much until you realize how hard you are pressing.. I really like the keyboard, it seemed pretty lame there was no function button on the left side! BUT, luckily, the MSI Dragon center came to the rescue and allows me to swap the functions of the right Fn key and windows key so I use it that way. It's really nice when I press the key and the keyboard goes dark to just illuminate the secondary function keys. Typing has taken me some time to get use to but It's like my old macbook pro and the font hasn't remotely bothered me. The speakers are a lot better than I anticipated (much better than my MBP) when I am playing music on spotify. The power cable coming off the right side is something you forget about literally instantly. It's not in the way and doesn't come close to interfering with my gskill mouse I use. The power brick is the size as my iPhone 6 plus and the thickness of a nickle. The track pad is on point and there were no freezes for me while using it. This thing is amazingly quiet, no noise from the fans during normal use and playing games on max setting and max fan it wasn't as loud as the GL703VM I have with a 1060. Hats off to ibuypower for getting it right and their technical support answering all my questions when I had them.hmscott, ctrlbrk and Donald@Paladin44 like this. -
Of course you can undervolt. How much depends on the well known Silicon lottery. But how long was Adam in paradise? Dust will come already after first weeks use. How much temp headreoom have you if the start point is bad and after some use? One thing is for sure... Temp will increase. And you will have to send in your toy. Time cost money. Some need their computers inhouse every day. A computer sitting on the tech depot won't make money. Only add cost.
And how many will manage the maintenance aka clean it up (even change thermal paste by themself) when temp start go wild due almost no temp headroom? As you can see... It's a reason resellers have to put up the prices a bit due how much work they put into, to give people less problems.
maintenance
Unlike the Aero 15X, which provides access to all major components, the GS65 has very limited maintenance options. After the case back has been freed of 15 Phillips screws, the underside can be pried out of the anchorage, but behind the plate only the fans, the battery and the radio module are waiting (see photo).
In order to achieve the graphics card, the processor, the main memory and the solid state drive, you would have to additionally unscrew the motherboard and turn around, which in itself would not be a major problem, but deters because of the many cables. In any case, the complicated maintenance ensures that the case score continues to slide downwards.
Donald@Paladin44, ThePerfectStorm and sk3tch like this. -
Thanks @Papusan. At the request of Donald at HIDEvolution I edited my post to reflect the 8C difference.
In my opinion, the $95 for liquid metal and Fujipoly was not worth it - but for those that want upgrades in a difficult to upgrade laptop, I do recommend HIDEvolution as an option. Just be careful with which thermal upgrades you choose - often factory is just fine with the availability of great software like Intel XTU and ThrottleStop. But hey, what do I know, I've only owned 4 Pascal laptops now.
P.S. my ultimate recommendation is to buy the GS65 from Best Buy for $2,000...Last edited: May 15, 2018hmscott and Donald@Paladin44 like this. -
I'm just picky and would rather max out a laptop config at the start, and know that 512 space would get small fast for a gaming machine (My desktop fills a 512 GB SSD really fast if I'm not careful).
So yeah, really appreciate your sharing!Donald@Paladin44 and sk3tch like this. -
Back on the road - first test of my HIDEvolution GS65 with LM + Fujipoly in ARK: Survival Evolved - with no undervolting the results are not that good considering the thermal "upgrade" - keyboard is hot to the touch while gaming which is crazy.
Donald reported top temps of 75C for GPU and 84C for CPU in their testing - so I guess they did not use demanding enough games or perhaps my laptop wasn't repasted properly?
hmscott likes this. -
Donald@Paladin44 Retired
I am not sure why you would think this means a bad Thermal Material application. @Mr. Fox @Falkentyne @Johnksss @bloodhawk @TBoneSan @Galm @saturnotaku or anyone want to comment on whether they think these results are attributable to a bad paste job? We would welcome the feedback.
The GPU temp is considerably higher than our testing revealed. Have you made any adjustments to your settings from what was delivered? Either way, I would recommend reaching out to our Tech Support/Warranty Service Team for help. That is what your Warranty is for. If you should ever need tech support or warranty service, please understand that I am not a technician, so it would be better to contact our Tech Support Team by phone at 888-666-3418 Extension 3, between 9:00 AM and 5:00 PM Pacific Time, Monday through Friday, by email at [email protected], or by Online Support Ticket at http://www.hidevolution.com/contacts/ (in the department dropdown menu select Zoltan S - Tech Support).
Please let me know if they don’t resolve your issue. -
Falkentyne Notebook Prophet
Brother @Donald@HIDevolution , I can't comment on this because I get extreme OCD and I instantly repaste if I ever have more than a 2C core temp difference in prime95. I tear down the heatsink, if the 'hotter' cores are on the sides closest to the thermal VRM pads, I lessen the pad thickness and if that doesn't work, I sand down the heatsink. I am an extreme nut job. My last 4.7 ghz cool room (not cold) run last night, with Prime95 small FFT with AVX disabled, was 83/82/83/83 after 10 minutes. Any core temp differences higher than 1C=LM repaste.
Trust me. I am a nut job.
Usually, temps within 3C under heavy balanced load is a great paste job. I consider >4C to be bad, because that means there is a danger of LM oxidation and dry out due to less pressure on the hotter sections and less pressure+heat stress can cause more uneven absorption of part of the LM alloy into the outer layers of the copper, leaving even weaker contact on those cores, and causing what I describe as "runaway cores."
This issue was seen extensively by @Ivan994 and @GENOCID and I think one other, maybe @JeanLegi until they all sanded down their convex heatsinks. -
this pic 2 weeks later it is with cooler boost on and after i use abrasive paper to sanded the heatsink.
you see that the temps between the cores is much better.
ctrlbrk, sk3tch and Donald@Paladin44 like this. -
Last edited: May 16, 2018Spartan@HIDevolution, ctrlbrk, raz8020 and 3 others like this.
-
On all the notebooks that I take apart above, only the surrounding edge of the pascal die have good pressure and the rest not so much. So this is why thick thermal paste like phobya nanogrease or even ICD can work better than LM.
If I don't readjust the heastink by bending (can only fix so much imperfection), normal thermal paste will do better since the gap is too big for liquid metal. However there's a limit to how much you can bend before damaging the copper.
In the future I will try lapping the heatsinks since I'm not very confident in doing that just yet. Tried to sand lightly but don't seem to affect temperatures that much since the contact improvements was very marginal.
Liquid metal can be used, just not optimal and needs significantly more amount when you apply which has its own issues of spill hazards.
GTX 1060 and below have smaller die size for the GPU, which might make adjustments to the heatsink easier.
Just my experience though, YMMVraz8020, Donald@Paladin44, Papusan and 1 other person like this. -
Last edited: May 16, 2018Ashtrix, Spartan@HIDevolution, ctrlbrk and 4 others like this. -
I recently had my sweet 5.6GHz 8700K running 20°C higher on core #5. (Yes, I said 20°C hotter on core #5, that is not a typo.) Could not for the life of me figure out why. It just started happening. I began an RMA process on the CPU. The day before the replacement CPU arrived it went back to normal with a small 3°C-6°C variance between the hottest to coldest core. The replacement CPU was a worthless piece of trash. Worst sample I have ever seen, in fact. It would barely handle 5.0GHz and took a ludicrous amount of voltage (1.425V for 50x6 LOL). I sent it back with a note that the replacement was worse than the one it was supposed to replace. And, I still don't know why it was running 20°C hotter on core #5. That problem has never resurfaced again. Really weird, but a good example of why stressing out over it probably burns more calories than what is warranted.
-
Thanks everyone. I am not as worried about the CPU temps but more the GPU. They are way out of spec for this machine, at least in terms of what has been reported for repasting results by HIDEvolution (and even without repasting - they had 79C stock, I'm at 87C with their liquid metal repaste and Fujipoly pads). I'm also not happy with the hot keyboard. I will engage support as a last option, because surely it means I will need to send the laptop back and I don't want to be without it for more than a few days (I have work trips weekly).
Here is more info:
- Windows 10 Pro, version 1803, all patches applied - 64-bit (no clean OS install done from HIDEvolution - I just uninstalled Norton)
- AV is Windows Defender
- NVIDIA driver is upgraded to 397.64
- Running programs while playing ARK: Survival Evolved (online): Discord, Steam, Dragon Center, SteelSeries Engine, MSI True Color, SCM
- Using the "Auto" fan profile.
- No undervolting
- No overclocking - all stock.
- 75 F room, flat wood desk
A couple more results from this AM - played about 45 min.
My next step is to undervolt while playing to see if that helps the overall system temps and perhaps the GPU.
Last edited: May 16, 2018hmscott and Donald@Paladin44 like this. -
This is a little random and off topic from your thermal talk but the sticker on the computer says 144hz 7ms ips level display (optional). I'm guessing that means they will provide an sku with a 4k display in the future?
Also. Can anyone help me with a guide to undervolting. I have MSI afterburner but I have no idea what I am doing. Any help would be appreciated. Thanks!Last edited: May 16, 2018Donald@Paladin44 likes this. -
Falkentyne Notebook Prophet
You guys are all talking about core temp differences, whether LGA or BGA. No one here however has hit the target.
@Donald@HIDevolution @Papusan @Mr. Fox
In my own excessive experiments with removing and repasting an ALREADY PERFECTLY sanded heatsink, here is what I found out.
In dealing with direct die contact, rather than a heatspreader IHS, two things greatly impact core temp differences (assuming a perfect flat heatsink; note that most current MSI CPU (used on the Titans that have the GT72/GT73 type block) sinks are convex, yet their GPU ones are mostly flat):
The first is applying enough LM.
Too little can be very bad. Since some of the alloy will always be absorbed into the very edge of the copper, applying too little and not compensating for this can actually leave the CPU dry with only hardened remaints of the non absorbed parts, causing hot spots over time, usually a few days. Applying a little too much and painting the heatsink with LM first (this also applies to the IHS--painting the underside of the IHS with LM has been proven on overclock.net to give lower temps than just CPU application alone) helps mitigate some of the battery effect and gives great longevity.
The second is the main problem:
Pressure when clamping the heatsink down.
On direct die, ANY variance in LM thickness can cause a several degree variance in temps, and uneven pressure, that is, having more pressure on one part of the core when applying initial pressure (even if you do partial turns and criss crosses on the screws) than another, can cause one core to be 3 or 4C higher than all the other cores, when a more careful pushing down would reduce this to 0C-1C. That's because LM is attracted to *ITSELF*, so uneven pressure right away can cause LM to shift away from part of the silicon. To avoid this, you need to first make sure the entire LM'd CPU surface has the exact same amount and thickness of LM, and then you apply full, completely even downwards pressure across the entire heatsink, when trying to get the screws to latch into the holes. This part--getting the screws to latch, if you are not careful, can create instant imbalance as you have to fight to get the first screw down, and this initial attempt can cause a core temp differential.
It's actually possible to have one core 4C higher than all the others right away, then when you remove the heatsink and look, you actually see that the LM, around that hot core, is almost pushed away from it.
The IHS for LGA mountings helps mitigate this somewhat by diffusing the heat more and spreading it to a larger area, as well as lack of oxidation effect on the LM (if only used between CPU and IHS), but this can also help de/relids as well.
Now I know ALL of you are going to hate me for what I am going to say now, but the BEST WAY to test for full and complete proper LM application and heatsink balance is PRIME95, with AVX disabled.
Prime95 with AVX disabled is only slightly more cpu intensive (small FFT) than Cinebench R15; Der8aeur tested this at 4-6% more, that is, prime95 @ 100% as baseline, Cinebench is 94%. That insures a fully consistent and balanced CPU load test. Also, problems with the LM application being unevenly spread can become apparent after 15 minutes of prime95 load testing between 80C to 88C.
You guys can take it or leave it.Ashtrix, raz8020, Donald@Paladin44 and 2 others like this. -
Thanks @Falkentyne - I ran Prime95 64-bit with Small FFTs for 15 minutes and here are my results. I could not find a setting to disable AVX - or does running the Small FFTs option take care of that?
I am running the "Auto" fan profile I am wondering if HIDEvolution ran theirs under "Cooler Boost" and did not disclose it?
hmscott and Donald@Paladin44 like this.
*** The Official MSI GS65 Stealth Owners and Discussions Lounge ***
Discussion in 'MSI Reviews & Owners' Lounges' started by Skylake_, Apr 3, 2018.