by Andrew Baxter
While cheap netbooks are all the rage these days, just a few months ago the attention was being lavished on expensive, high-end thin and light notebooks. Namely the 13.3" screen Apple MacBook Air and Lenovo ThinkPad X300. Fast forward several months and several hundred stock market points lower and expensive laptops don't seem quite as appealing, which might be why the recent release of the Lenovo ThinkPad X301 was mostly a silent entrance on stage left. Still, if you're a CEO that happens to still have a job these days and you like to have the latest and greatest in ultra-mobile computing technology, cost not being a concern, the ThinkPad X301 could be a fit.
Overview
Before going too far we'll preface this review by saying it's going to sound a whole lot like the X300 review we did back in February. That's simply because the new X301 is just a refresh to the X300, and design wise everythingremains the same. Internally you have a new Montevina platform Intelchipsetand Lenovo also saw fit to add a DisplayPortinterface this time around, but other than that we're talking carbon copy of the X300 here. Which isn't a bad thing by any means, since the X300 won high praise.
The review unit ThinkPad X301 we havecomes with the following specs:
- Processor: 1.40GHz Intel Core 2 Duo SU9400 (1.40GHz, 3MB L2 cache, 800Mhz FSB)
- Graphics: Intel Graphics Media Accelerator 4500MHD
- Screen: 13.3-inch WXGA+ (1440 x 900, 300 nit) LED backlit display
- Memory: 2GB (up to 4GB configurable)
- Storage: 64GB SSD (up to 128GB SSD optional)
- Optical Drive: Ultra-thin DVD Burner
- Wireless and Communications: Intel Wi-Fi Link 5100 (802.11 a/b/g/n wi-fi), BlueTooth 2.0 EDR (Verizonor AT&T 3Gwireless available as option, not included)
- Battery: 6-cell Li-Polymer extended life battery (3-cell Li-Polymer battery available and multi-bay extended life 3-cell battery)
- Ports: 3 USB 2.0 ports, Monitor out port, AC adapter, headphone/line-out, microphone/line-in, Gigabit Ethernet
- Dimensions: 12.4" x 9.1" x 0.73" - 0.92"
- Weight: from 2.93lbs with 3-cell battery and no optical drive to 3.32lbs with 6-cell battery and DVD Burner in
- Port Replicator: Via USB
- Input: Full sized keyboard, trackpoint navigation, touchpad, fingerprint reader
- Operating System: Windows XP Professional (Windows Vista available in various flavors)
- Other Features: Integrated web camera
- Price: About $3,000
- Warranty: 1-year
Notice the dimensions of the X301, it is well under 1-inch thick, meaning it's easy to slip into a bag for carrying purposes. The light weight makes that doubly the case.
Build and Design
The ThinkPad X301 is as solid as you get in terms of build quality. The internal chassis and roll cage use an advanced carbon-fiber / glass-fiber material that provides both strength and light weight. The case material is made of magnesium, press as hard as you want anywhere on the body of the notebook and it will not flex. Likeall ThinkPads, the X301 is designed for accidental abuse and drops.The screen is held down using alatch mechanism with button release, something that's more and more rare these days withnotebooks as most other manufacturersmove to a latchless design.
The build quality leaves no doubtsand the X301 design also makes it standout. That said, there's nothing crazy going on here, the black boxy look of a ThinkPad is still very much so intact. However, the glossy bottom bezel area and the cool light illumination on the ThinkVantage button and power button add a nice touch, plus add to the usability. The speakers located on the frontcorners of the notebook add a nice design accent. The heat vent grills are painted black to blend with the rest of the notebook design, you don't see any copper colored internals. The screen is centered for those hung up on symmetry. And last and probably most important, the X301 is very thin,a cool look by de facto.
The weight of the X301 with a 3-cell battery and weight saver can get you under the magic 3lb mark at 2.93lbs. If you're going to be unplugged for any duration of time you'll probably want the 6-cell battery, which bumps the weight to 3.32lbs. Still a very comfortable weight to be carrying.
Input and Output PortsThe ThinkPad engineers have done a great job of squeezing in as many useful ports in a thin design that they can. Indeed, the X301 adds an extra port to the mixover the X300in the form of the DisplayPort located on the back.
Here's what's included:
- 3 USB 2.0 ports (2 on the left, 1 on the back)
- Gigabit Ethernet(back)
- Audio out, microphone in (left side)
- Monitor out (back)
- DisplayPort (back)
Three USB ports is very generous forthis size and dimensionlaptop. It would have been very nice to have a media card reader slot, especially an SDHC compatible one so that you could quickly boost storage capacity.
Keyboard and Touchpad
The full-sized keyboard on the ThinkPad X301 remains the same as that on the X300. Ithas no flex, every key feels individual, and the keytravel distance is perfect.Lenovo has added a matte finish to the keys so that they don't wear and get all shiny over time. For added usability the Caps Lock has a green light indicator and the power button a white light toshow power is on.
People that like a touchpad and complain about it being missing on the ThinkPad X200-series have nothing to complain about here, a decent sized touchpad with scrolling areas is in place on the X301. This reviewer actually prefers the TrackPoint pointing stick over the touchpad and exclusively uses that method of input, but in testing out the touchpad it was found to be responsive and the size adequate.
Just to the right of the touchpad is a fingerprint reader, a feature common to many business notebooks. The palm rest area is especially comfortable, it has a rubberized paint finish so it both feels and looks nice. It's very smooth and pleasing to the touch, almost satin in feel.
Performance and Benchmarks
The ThinkPad X301 is not built to compete with your Quad Core processor loaded desktop. The name of the game with thin travel notebooks is using a low voltage processor to conserve power and reduce heat build-up. The ThinkPad X301 uses a newly releasedIntel 1.40GHz Core 2 Duo SU9400 processor from the Montevina family chipset. The X300 used a 1.20GHzL7100chip especially designed by Intel for that notebook (so Lenovo claimed), but the SU9400 appears to be a more standard processor that other manufacturers might use. Apparently the 45nm fabrication process the SU9400 was developed on shrank things enough to mitigate Lenovo needing any further "shrinking tricks" by Intel engineers.
The SU9400 processor inside the X301is more thancapable of running Office applications and performing any general web related tasks, but will not serve well for 3D graphics applications or any heavy duty rendering tasks. The Intel integrated graphics will allow you to play a few light games, maybe even Half Life 2 on low settings, but in general you'll want to stick to e-mail, web browsing, Office and photo editing tasks. In other words, what most normal business people use a laptop for.
The SSD storage really goes a long way to improving certain aspects of performance, the all important boot-up time is afast 28-seconds from the push of the power button to the Windows hourglass disappearing. It only took 32 seconds to boot-up, have the wireless connection enabled, and a browser window open to its homepage.
Let's take a look at a couple of basic benchmarks so you can get an idea of how the X301 stacks up.
PCMark05 is a benchmark that measures the overall system performance, so it considers the processor, hard drive, memory and OS as part of the mix. You'll notice in the results the X301 takes a 1,000 point leap over the previous score of the X300, and the MacBook Air score is close to doubled:
PCMark05 benchmark results (higher scores are better)
Notebook PCMark05 Score Lenovo ThinkPad X301 (Intel Core 2 Duo SU9400 @ 1.40GHz, Intel 4500MHD) 4,457 PCMarks Lenovo ThinkPad X300 (Intel Core 2 Duo L7100 @ 1.20GHz, Intel X3100) 3,467 PCMarks Apple MacBook Air (1.6GHz Intel Core 2 Duo P7500, Intel X3100) 2,478 PCMarks Sony VAIO NR (1.5GHz Intel Core 2 Duo T5250, Intel X3100) 3,283 PCMarks Sony VAIO TZ (1.20GHz Core 2 Duo U7600, Intel GMA 950) 2,446 PCMarks Lenovo ThinkPad X61 (2.0GHz Intel Core 2 Duo T7300, Intel X3100) 4,153 PCMarks Lenovo 3000 V200 (2.0GHz Intel Core 2 Duo T7300, Intel X3100) 3,987 PCMarks Lenovo T60 Widescreen (2.0GHz Intel T7200, ATI X1400 128MB) 4,189 PCMarks HP dv6000t (2.16GHz Intel T7400, NVIDA GeForce Go 7400) 4,234 PCMarks Fujitsu N6410 (1.66GHz Core Duo, ATI X1400) 3,487 PCMarks Sony VAIO SZ-110B in Speed Mode (Using Nvidia GeForce Go 7400) 3,637 PCMarks Asus V6J (1.86GHz Core Duo T2400, Nvidia Go 7400) 3,646 PCMarks The X301 has the new Intel 4500MHD integrated graphics on board. The 3D performance actually gets quite a bump from the previous X300 thanks to this upgrade, over 200 points higher in 3DMark06:
3DMark06 comparison results (higher score meens better performance):
Notebook 3DMark06 Score Lenovo ThinkPad X301 (Intel Core 2 Duo SU9400 @ 1.40GHz, Intel 4500MHD) 712 3DMarks Lenovo ThinkPad X300 (Intel Core 2 Duo L7100 @ 1.20GHz, Intel X3100) 475 3DMarks Apple MacBook Air (1.6GHz Intel Core 2 Duo P7500, Intel X3100) 502 3DMarks Sony VAIO NR (1.5GHz Intel Core 2 Duo T5250, Intel X3100) 504 3DMarks Toshiba Tecra M9 (2.20GHz Core 2 Duo T7500, NVIDIA Quadro NVS 130M 128MB) 1,115 3DMarks Sony VAIO TZ (1.20GHz Core 2 Duo U7600, Intel GMA 950) 122 3DMarks HP dv2500t (2.0GHz Intel Core 2 Duo T7300, NVIDIA GeForce Go 8400M GS 128MB) 1,055 3DMarks HP dv6000t (2.16 GHz Intel T7400, NVIDA GeForce Go 7400) 827 3DMarks Battery
Lenovo offers the choice of either a 3-cell or 6-cell Lithium-Polymer battery that rests at the front of the notebook. The 3-cell is lighter and has a quoted life of up to 4.3 hours while the 6-cell is heavier and has a quoted life of up to 6.5 hours. You can also get a 3-cell Lithium-Polymer option bay battery, to install you just pull out the DVD Burner, which is easily done by removing one screw, and then insert the spare battery instead (note, you have to shut down to do that, there is no hot swap option).
We did a couple of battery tests. In the first test we had the following settings:
- Battery: 6-cell Li-Ion extended life battery
- Radios: Wi-Fi on
- Usage: Idling with screen on
- Vista Power Setting: Power Saver
- Screen brightness: 7 / 15 bars
- DVD Burner: On but never used
Under this non-realistic style usage we achieved4 hours and50 minutes of battery life, at which time there was 6% battery left and the X301 went into hibernation.
For a more realistic test, we used the following settings:
- Battery: 6-cell Li-Ion extended life battery + 3-cell Media Bay battery
- Radios: all on
- Usage: used for web surfing, working on review, downloading and installing software
- Vista Power Setting: Power Saver
- Screen: 7/15 bar
With this typical work scenario setting the battery reached 6% remaining and went into hibernate at 7 hours and 12 minutes. Note that the 3-cell battery is used up first and the main battery is then switched to seamlessly, you won't even notice it happen. The X301 does weigh a few ounces more when you put the 3-cell media bay battery in, but the extra weight is worth the battery life if that's what you value most from a laptop.
Screen
The 13.3" WXGA+ matte (non-glossy) screen on the X301 is nice and bright, with its 300 nit LED backlit spec. The screen real estate you get with WXGA+ on the 13.3" form factor is actually more than you'd expect, you can quite comfortably fit a couple of web browser or spreadsheet windows open next to each other and compare and contrast things.
The viewing angles are good, especially the horizontal viewing angles. Thanks in part to the bright screen; it is very easy to view things even if you are almost totally off to the side.
Heat and Noise
One major concern with a laptop that's extremely thin is that it will overheat due to all of the components being crammed together. To combat this issue Lenovo went with an Intel Core 2 Duo 1.40GHz low voltage processor, less power draw means less heat. Heat never became an issue with the X301, it was completely comfortable to use in the lap and the palm rests never got warm.
Temperatures on the palm rest and keyboard area remained low (view large image)
Temperatures on the bottom only got mildly warm (view large image)The fan located on the back left side of the X301 ran fairly frequently and at a constant rate. It wasn't particularly loud or annoying, with ambient room noise it was hard to hear the fan at all. Though in a more quiet room the fan is certainly audible.
Connectivity and Wireless
The ThinkPad X301has a great array of connectivityand wireless offerings. Included in the mix are:
- WLAN Wi-Fi 802.11 a/b/g/n
- WAN (Verizon or AT&T 3G services)
- UWB (optional)
- GPS (optional, available only with Verizon card)
- Ethernet LAN port
- BlueTooth
Notice there is no modem included, you'll have to use a dongle modem extension if you want that. We don't miss this port being built-in as it's been years since we had to use a modem. The integrated WAN and WLAN will combine to keep you connected just about anywhere on the road, the UWB is an option for roaming wireless but you won't find many cities in the U.S. that offer this.
Audio
The X301 actually has good sound and speakers that are well positioned. For an ultra thin notebook, that's astounding. The ThinkPad X61/X200 contain a puny speaker on the bottom of the notebook, so this is something of a quantum leap for audio quality on the X-series. ThinkPad X301 equipped executives will never have to tote their external speakers to watch DVDs by night in their hotel rooms again.
Conclusion
The ThinkPad X301 takes the original X300 and adds a nice performance jump with the new Intel SU9400 Montevina family processor plus adds a DisplayPort to the mix. Also available now is a 128GB SSD option, though this costs $400 more than the standard 64-bit SSD, if you're buying the X301 price probably isn't too much of a concern for you. The $3,000 laptop market is certainly an exclusive group of buyers, but for many business people their laptop and Blackberry are a lifeline to getting work and deals done, and thereby money made. So at the end of the day if you're a globe trotting executive that needs a reliable and top of the line work tool, the cost of the X301 can be jusitifed and this slim form factor machine can serve you well.
Pros
- Under 1-inch thick, the thinnest ThinkPad ever
- Light weight and easy for carrying around in a bag
- Superb build quality and feel, nice design touches added
- Built-in optical drive for such a thin notebook is a rarity
- Improved performance over the X300. Great for normal business tasks, very fast bootup with the SSD
- Very bright screen for easy viewing
Cons
- No SD media card reader
- No expansion dock capability, USB based port replicator only
- No ExpressCard or PC card slot
- Starting price of $2,500 is out of range for many people
-
-
I think I'll stick to the X200. A full power Core 2 Duo, 10 hours of battery life with the 9 cell battery, and its half the price of the X301. Granted, its not as thin, nor does it have an optical drive or an SSD, and has a lower resolution screen, but the CPU power and pricing easily makes up for that.
-
How is the battery life compared to the X300? From another review I read, it seemed like the battery life is actually quite a bit less.
-
Excellent review,thx!
-
Nice test, but why there's never a playback test of H.264 encoded 1080p files? Like my legally backed up blu-ray collection? The performance of the X4500HD graphics would be of great interest to me... :|
-
Yeah. I'd like to see a more detailed comparison of the X3100 and X4500HD, not just performance but also power consumption. I tend to buy laptops with the integrated Intel graphics because the drivers are open source and just work better in Linux.
-
Thanks for the review. Up to what resolution does the displayport support? Would it, for example, support a Dell 30 inch monitor?
-
Too bad there is no HDD option which I'm sure many don't mind having its drawbacks vs an SSD to have a substantially lower starting price
I thought I read a few months back that the X300 would start out with an SSD but get HDD options later on? -
Andrew, Can I borrow this notebook for a little while? I PROMISE to return it in one piece! Well, No I don't, But I'll take good care of it! And, As always, nice review!
-
I wish that Lenovo would allow people to configure a standard HD in this notebook so that it could bring the price down. This processor does not appear to improve on the battery life compared to the P type processors etc.
This laptop is a little bit to bland looking for me but the leather one the x300 that they were offering has a bit more going on about it. My Sony is black as well but at least it has got a nice carbon fibre lid going for it.
7 hours 12 mins downloading and installing software with meduim brightness with WAN, Bluetooth and wifi on is not bad at all. You should be able to get at least 8 hours 30 minutes battery life with wifi just on surfing with the 9 cell battery and more if you turned wifi of and just did office work. Turning of the DVD drive would also save a little bit of power.
Is the 6 cell battery even a standard 5200mAh battery?
I think that the 4500HD graphics card is going to draw a little more power than the x3100 graphics card as the 4500HD is more powerful and capable. -
In case you did not notice, 7 hours and 12 minutes was reached with 9 cells.
-
That isn't such a good score since this thing here should perform better than the X200s. Either it hasn't got the newest technology in terms of batteries or there is a big hole through which all the energy escapes...
-
Hi Phil i did realise that the 7 hours 12 mins was obtained with the 9 cell battery.
Mr. Cameltoe i doubt if the x200 actually has better battery life than this notebook. There might not be much in it and they might be pretty much the same. The battery test that this notebook had with 9 cell battery was very intensive with all radios turned on.
In the review of the x200 in this forum the first battery test was not intensive at all and the computer was basically left in idle the majority of the time. The other test the user did looked like it was on par with the x301 battery life but then not all is equal to begin with anyway.
I took the below quote from the x200 review on this forum.
-
Well, it sucks that it's so pricey, but at least the ThinkPad quality is still there, and it's a pleasant surprise about the audio!
-
Thanks for the review. I currently have the X300 and find it to be a great laptop. I find the performance to be stellar especially for my needs (photography, business work).
I travel quite a bit so the weight, durable aspects of the X300 is highly coveted. With that said I placed an order for the X301 with employee pricing so I think I got a good deal especially with the all upgrades I selected (128 SSD, WWAN, 3gb RAM, Wifi 5300, and everything else in between).
With the better performance as stated by Andrew I think the X301 is good choice at the moment. -
-
Thinks for your sharing!
-
PC Mag also reviewed this laptop recently and they found the X301 to have improved on the battery life of the x300 a little.
These comparison tests were done with a 6 cell battery and all with integrated graphics except for the Sony SZ7 which they tested with the dedicated GPU.
http://www.pcmag.com/image_popup/0,1871,iid=217459,00.asp -
Thank you for the link to the PCmag performance chart. That clearly shows the battery life of the X301 to be better than the X300. My understanding is that the whole chipset in the X301 is more efficient and draws less power. Since the graphics card is integrated, it wouldn't be an issue.
The X301 is going on my wish list.
why isn't there a smiley for :drool: ? -
Can someone clarify whether or not the x301 supports dual external monitors? i.e. can the DisplayPort and VGA outputs be used concurrently to display different images?
In my office, I'd like to run two 19" LCDs off of the laptop - one from the DisplayPort and the other from the VGA (and not use the laptop LCD). I want to extend my desktop accross the two monitors, not clone it.
None of the past x series models have supported this feature and haven't found anything conclusive in the product literature. -
Red_Dragon Notebook Nobel Laureate
i would buy a thinkpad if lenovo actually decided to change the styling......its time they changed the styling to something new sometimes it is good to change the formula. The again, it is a winning formula.
-
-
I agree that the design of the x301 is very good. Although personally I prefer to have the SDHC reader, 54mm expresscard, modem, and dock connector offered by the x200(s) over the DVD drive of the x301. Further, having 9 cells of battery disposes of the one real advantage the x301 has (DVD), while it only adds 1 inch and a few ounces to the x200(s). -
-
Wonder if a Tripple head to go from Matrox would work?
Maybe thats an option for you?
ym -
You would need to use something like the Matrox DualHead2Go or TripleHead2Go if you want >2 displays. The 4500MHD is a dual head card and is only capable of driving two displays simultaneously. The Matrox adapter would just trick the display adapter into thinking 2 or 3 external monitors is just one big one. This also only works on VGA and quality may be subpar as you are driving a 3840x1024 display from a single VGA connector.
If you open up presentation director you have the option of internal only, VGA only, Displayport only, internal/VGA, internal/Displayport, or VGA/Displayport (internal disabled). I believe only a select few cards (usually pro grade cards for financial services) support >2 displays. -
Hello,
In the test of the Lenovo X301, Andrew presents temperature of the body, he speaks about heat : it's between 80 and 90. But I want to know what is his scale : Celsius or Fahrenheit ? I leave in Paris and I use only Celsius.
Can somebody answer me ? Thank you. -
gary_hendricks Notebook Evangelist
Thanks for this review. I think Lenovo is starting to push in the correct direction.
-
-
damn
so many review sites are duped
But this one looks okay. Problem here is:
I am having a 18deg Fahrenheit HOTTER x301 than you (what tool did you use to measure the temp? I use tpfand )!
Okay, I have a SU9600, but it's obviously never running at at 1600MHz, more around 800MHz since I only use office tools.
Here's my full report on the X301:
Pros:
* keyboard writing
* full linux compatibility (kubuntu 9.4)
* fabric very comfortable
* screen brightness-control
* feels very light
* speaker/mic feedback-cancellation
Cons:
* fan
* battery lifetime
* cleavages!
* not as slim as propagated
* USB ports narrower than usual
I'm not very rich but I like lenovo's durability (my last box lasted 6 years) so I jumped over the gap.
I landed safely: I love my new X301 but since I don't believe reviews a lot, mostly because of fake reviews.
Anyway, email me, if you disagree with my rev. or have further questions: patrick dot fehr at fbc dot ch.
Detailled Pros:
* keyboard writing goes very smoothly, like tapping on clouds.
* under linux (kubuntu 9.4) everyhing important works out of the box (!!).
* the fabric is very comfortable for the palms
* the screen brightness has 16(!) levels from VERY bright to almost dark.
* the model is (as you can read EVERYWHERE) very light, feels kind of having a toy in your hand!
* all basic funtionality (wlan, webcam, ethernet, usb) works flawlessly
* the speakers are N I C E: You can use skype without external mic or headphone because somehow they managed to cancel the acoustic feedback. LOVING this!
Detailled Cons:
* Fan: This is the biggest issue: The fan ALWAYS runs at 5000RPM which is hearable and annoying with time. I had to create my own tpfan-profile. Now my baby is silent.
* Battery lifetime: As we all know, you always have to divide the spec's number by 2 and this is true here, too: I have - under normal conditions(~avg. 20%CPU usage)-approx. 4 hours until I get to 10% battery and have to plug it in. Hm, this is not really a Contra, but an adviser to never trust these numbers(8hours)!
* cleavages: I'm sorry Lenovo but there are still TOO MANY cleavages(german: Spalten), not only around the keyboard-keys but also everywhere on the sides, the lid.. This is where the dust goes and I don't like cleaning a lot -
How did you get a hold of an X301 with SU9600 CPU? This isn't a configuration option yet on the Lenovo site.
If you want to avoid cleavages, get a unibody Macbook. It is the most cleavage free laptop I've ever owned.
p.s. I don't mind cleavages as long as they aren't on my laptop -
Dear undoIT
Indeed, I specified it to be a SU9600, myself.
I bought it under www.studentenrabatt.ch (no worries, don't have to be a student, they even refused me sending them a copy of my legitimation card, lol)
If you need more information, don't hesitate to write me an email, you find the adress in my review up there.
Best regards
Patrick -
I have bought an X301 too.
I think it was the investment of the year for me...
So, I absolutely agree with your all pros and cons. It is a great configure but the most annoying is the fan...
It is horrible.
All in all I installed this smart TPfancontroll program today. But some questions are came up.
Pls. try to help me to specify the settings!
First of all which setting is the best...?
Bios?
As I know it's same as the factory settings...
Smart1?
My CPU is 61celsius and the fun is still sleeping... ( I am afraid of the damages...)
Smart2?
It's worse than the factory settings... (It seems to me that the fan always run with high speed...)
Or Manual...?
I don't know the right settings... (e.g. max. cpu temp...etc.)
As I read you using manual settings. What are your base levels...?
Thanks in advance!
Biga -
So, with the SSD, now the fan is becoming an issue ? I hope mine does not sound ultra-loud. I just ordered an X301 a few days ago, and should be here mid-December. (there is a minimum 4 week wait for X301 orders for some reason).
-
I had not seen this review. Thanks! Very well done and a great read!
-
I don't know what happened, maybe Lenovo decided to switch panel types midstream, because I just received my X301 yesterday and I'm already ready to send it back.
This is hands down the worst LCD screen I've ever seen. The black levels are horrible, truly horrible. The blackest blacks feel like a 90% black on any other LCD. The viewing on angles on this remind me of the worst TN panels ever, and there's this texture that's visible on areas of solid bright color that I don't have on any of my other LCD screens, desktop or laptop. If that texture is the anti-glare, I've never seen it have that effect on a screen.
Really, really frustrated and upset.
Lenovo ThinkPad X301 Review
Discussion in 'Notebook News and Reviews' started by Andrew Baxter, Sep 18, 2008.