by Derek Duncan, Missouri USA
I've never owned a laptop before. I'm a student and wanted a notebook small enough to place on a desk in lecture halls, but notso drastically small that I couldn't see the screen well. So when I sat down to think of what I wanted in a laptop, a few things came to mind for my needs:
- Long battery life (3.5 hrs+)
- Light weight (under 5.5 lbs)
- Nice look
- Good performance
- Around $1,000
Those aren't lofty requirements, but you'd be surprised how difficult it is to find a laptop that contains all ofthese aspects. My choices came down to four laptops: theHP dv1000, Fujitsu S6231, Apple PowerBook and the Gateway 3520GZ (or Gateway M210 if purchased directly from Gateway).
The Fujitsu and PowerBook were priced a little bit out of my range, an iBook didn't have the specs I was looking for, I could get a much better PC laptop for the same price. So it came down to the dv1000 or the 3520GZ. I went to Best Buy to try them both out. Both are very nice looking laptops, with the Gateway being slightly larger, though both notebooks sport 14.1-inch widescreen displays.
This review is not meant as a comparison, but you'll see why I chose the 3520GZ/M210 over the dv1000 and other similar notebooks after reading through
Gateway 3520GZ / Gateway M210 Specs:
- Pentium M 725 (1.6 Dothan)
- 512MB PC2700 DDR RAM (expandable to 1.25GB)
- 60GB 4200RPM hard drive
- Integrated Intel Extreme 2 graphics with 32mb shared memory
- Multiformat DVD+/-RW/CDRW (8X DVD/24X CDRW)
- 14.1-inch Ultrabright WXGA TFT widescreen display
- Intel PRO/Wireless LAN (802.11b/g)
- Weight 5.25 lbs
- PurchasePrice: $1099 at Best Buy
Appearance/Build
Upon first look at the 3520GZ, you'll notice that the interior is a lot less cluttered than something like the dv1000, with no labeling where USB ports or VGA ports are. It looks really clean cut with the silver finish and black keyboard. There arefive tiny icons that light up blue when in use along the bottom of the unusually small touchpad, with the power button on the top right of the machine. You can turn off the blue backlights by simply holding the Function+F1 key. The battery fits flushed with the bottom of the system, although it seems to stick out through the back.
The 3520GZ features a full-size keyboard and solid construction. When you close the lid, there's no wiggle-room. One nice aspect is the two headphone jacks in the front like the dv1000, so two people can listen at a time.
The 3520GZ feels well built, it is probably prone to scratches due to the outside of the lid being painted silver, but it definitely does not feel cheap. One might question it's durability, as compared with anIBM or Apple built laptop, but those notebooksare priced accordingly and hopefullyyou'lltake care of your purchase and keep it in good condition anyway, so it shouldn't be a problem. Let's just say this laptop feels more sturdy than the dv1000 when I checked it out.
One odd thing is that the speakers are actually on the bottom of the laptop. Why Gateway decided to do this is beyond my comprehension.
Size/Weight
The 3520GZ measures just 1.2" high, 9.7" wide and 13" long. It's slightly bigger than the dv1000, but weighs just 5.25 lbs. Although you could get lighter notebooks, for the price of this one, around 5 lbs is the best you're going to do.Screen
I'll say this about the 14.1-inch Ultrabright widescreen display - it's gorgeous. It's a lot less reflective than the dv1000's screen in my opinion. It's still a bit reflective, but not annoyingly so. And viewing DVD's on this screen is a charm. And even though you don't think you'll notice the extra space on the widescreen display, I got on my 17" LCD on my desktop after using the 3520GZ and the desktop appeared MUCH smaller. Once you go widescreen, you'll never go back.
Performance
This laptopcan multitask with ease due to it's 512MB RAM, although 32mb is shared with the graphics. I burned a dvd in just around 15 minutes with it's 8X DVD burner. The one thing I was skeptical about was the integrated video, but it runs surprisingly well. I don't game, but you might think you need dedicated graphics, but if you don't game or utilize 3D-heavy programs, you won't even notice the lack of a dedicated graphics card. Personally I don't know why anybody would want to game on a small laptop that's supposed to be a lightweight machine. But it's definitely adequate for everyday use.The 60GB hard drive is good for the price.256MB RAM is actually on the motherboard, so you'll only be able to add 1GB more for a total of 1.25 (just like Apple). Wish you could access both, but the 1.6 Dothan processor makes up for it. Another thing about the RAM, it's actually PC2700, but the motherboard only supports 266mhz, according to the Gateway specifications website, so I'm a bit fuzzy on if the motherboard will take advantage of the higher speed.
Keyboard/Touchpad
I feel the keyboard and touchpad input is a very important factor when deciding on a laptop,as you'll spend all of your timeusing thesetwo features. The keyboard feels very solid. It feels more responsive than other laptops I've tried. The touchpad is smaller than most every other touchpad I've seen on a notebook. A portion is set aside for scrolling. The buttons are small rounded bars and the right-click button seems very tiny, that will take some getting used to.
Battery Life
This was probably the most important aspect of a notebook to me. I've seen smaller laptops with shorter battery life. But the 3520GZ will not disappoint. I consistently get around 4 hours with wi-fi on while I'm surfing the net, listening to music, even viewing a few mpeg movies. You can turn off wi-fi with the Function+F2 button. I viewed an hour and 30 minute dvd with wi-fi on at times and still had 53% battery left. You can turn screen brightness down as much as you'd like and it's still comfortable viewing. I think Gateway promises around 4.5 hours average and there's no reason to think that this machine can't deliver on that claim.
The AC adapter is smaller compared to other AC adapters. And it's light enough that when you carry it with you, you won't notice the extra weight.
Sound
The 3520GZ speakers are not good. They are just the same as any other laptop s speakers, minus the dv1000. With them being placed on the bottom, I don't think Gateway cared either. There is a volume control on the front of the notebook for easy access while viewing DVDs or listening to music. But I just plug in my headphones and go from there. In fact, you'll notice how average the speakers are until you plug in a good pair of headphones.
Expandability
There is lots of room for expansion here. You can replace the hard drive, upgrade the memory, though still just to 1.25gb. You can connect the notebook to an external monitor and with three usb ports and firewire, this can be a digital media center. Though all three usb ports are right next to eachother on the right side. Also built-in is a media card reader for various flash memory cards.
Conclusions
With this notebook being released the end of November, it's hard to tell if there's any bugs to report. I haven't found any as of yet. No clock issues or high pitch noises yet. With all the features you get in a notebook, you can't beat this one for the price. Gateway might have just found a winner in the notebook department.
Pricing and Availability
PROS
- 14.1" widescreen
- Above average keyboard
- Long battery life
- DVDBurner
- Large hard drive
CONS
- Small touchpad/buttons
- Maybe prone to scratches
- Integrated graphics
-
-
Great review abaxter!
I bought the same laptop from Best Buy and I just wanted to point out a few things.
First, I had the option of buying this laptop from either Gateway direct or Best Buy. I chose Best Buy because they have a very consumer-friendly buying policy. That is, before I actually took the laptop home, they checked it for any defects, free of charge. If any defects were to be found, I had the option of returning the laptop for a full refund. This free initial check really eased my mind about potential dead pixels. For some reason, direct online shops like Gateway will only return a laptop you buy "new" if there are a number (i.e. more than three or so) of dead pixels. I don't know how people can live with a screen that has a dead pixel(s) when the laptop is suppose to be "new".
Second, I noticed that abaxter mentioned that the laptop had two headphone jacks. I checked my laptop and that isn't the case. Instead of two headphone jacks, I have one that is demarked as a microphone jack and the other being the headphone jack. Perhaps there is more than one version.
I also wanted to point out that this laptop does not, in any remote way, get hot. After three to four hours of heavy use (dvds, compiling, wireless use, emu games) the laptop stayed cool to the touch. However, the only thing that got really hot was the power brick. Speaking of the power brick, that thing is relatively small and doesn't weight much at all. It's just a little heavier than my cell phone wall charger.
I concur with Abaxter on the keyboard. It is solid. No flex of any kind, anywhere. The keys go down deep enough. I was thinking about getting the sony vaio S, but I noticed the keys don't go down deep enough to feel comfortable to type without wondering if you actually pressed a key. But I suspect this may be a subjective matter.
Overall, I am extremely pleased with Best Buy and the laptop. The only thing one should watch out for is the integrated video "card". Fortunately, I am more of a classic gamer and very much enjoy retro games like Final Fantasy for the SNES and Phantasy Star II,IV for the Genesis. You can run those, assuming you own the originals.
CK -
Are you still happy with this laptop? How is the battery life up until now? Is there an extended battery option like an 8 cell or something? How are graphics? Are you happy with Gateway right now with regard to service?
Gateway M210 / 3520GZ Review (pics, specs)
Discussion in 'Notebook News and Reviews' started by Andrew Baxter, Jan 6, 2005.