does the MBP "whine?"

hey guys,

I bought a hp dv6563cl a few weeks ago...and a couple blue screens later I'm getting very mad! I fixed that problem but one that refuses to go away is the high pitched "whining" noise coming from the CPU (+the fact that I am very sensitive to noise). Luckily I bought this from Costco, so I'm returning it tomorrow. Has anybody had any problems with high pitched noises coming from their MBP (I heard there was and then there was a fix by Apple?) ? I want to buy the $1999 base model. Thanks.

 

Slap some sense into it and tell it to stop whining and take it like a man.

No, the MBP no longer whines (or it shouldn't). The fans hum when they get up really high, but that's the same for all laptops.

 

well a processor is a processor, and its not like they have some soundproof casing or something to put it in. but no i dont think anybody has had problems with a whine on their MBP.

 

http://forum.notebookreview.com/showthread.php?t=157365&highlight=whine

 

I had an HP 9000t earlier this year, and it had that horrible high-pitched whine. Our MBP (which replaced the HP) is very quiet and has no whine.

 

Maybe some shock but no whine at least from mine.

 

i don't notice any annoying noise from my mbp. the new ones released in june of this year probably took that problem out.

 

yes the macbooks whine, all core2duos whine. you have to be def not to hear it.

 

I don't notice any whine. My MacBook is extremely quiet, I can barely hear the fans.

I rarely hear whines even when checking out the different notebooks at Future Shop (Canada's version of Best Buy).

 

After I hit my MBP repeatedly, it started whine and then cried for a few hours. And after I left it alone, it went to sleep.

 

no whine on mine , none whatsoever . none , zero, nada, zilch.